THE IMPACT ANALYSIS OF THE NOISE SCREENS ON THE EXAMPLE OF A TRANSPORT INTERCHANGE IN THE CITY OF OMSK
https://doi.org/10.26518/2071-7296-2020-17-2-286-301
Abstract
Introduction. Noise pollution is one of the three most significant environmental disruptions in the world. In urban areas, the main source of noise is road transport, which accounts up to 80% of all noise. Noise protection measures are an integral part of the design both at the feasibility study stage and during a project development. In the conditions of cramped urban development, high density of the road network and the shortage of free territories, it is more appropriate to use noise protection structures in the form of roadside noise (acoustic) screens - vertical walls that are installed as close as possible to the highway. However, as the experience has shown, in operating conditions, noise screens do not always fully fulfill their protective function. This article presents a critical analysis of the effectiveness of the noise screens installation on the example of a traffic interchange on 15th Rabochaia in Omsk.
Materials and methods. The evaluation of the effectiveness of the design solutions for the installation of noise screens and the execution of these solutions was carried out with two methods. The first method is calculating. The calculation of the noise impact from the traffic flow on the residential development was carried out according to the methodology of ODM 218.2.013-2011 the Guidelines for the protection from traffic noise of territories adjacent to the roads. To perform the calculations, the content and intensity of the movement of transport at each section of the interchange was determined. The geometric parameters on the object are set. The second method is experimental. To confirm the calculation results, the full-scale measurements of the noise level at nine points at the indicated interchange were carried out.
Results. Based on the results of the calculation it was concluded that the current noise protection structures do not fully fulfill their function. A residential development in the area under consideration is located in the noise discomfort zone. The results of field measurements are confirmed by calculated data. The article gives recommendations for correcting the shortcomings made in the design and construction of the noise screens.
Conclusion. Considering the results of the research presented in this article and published earlier, it is advisable to consider the reconstruction of the transport interchange on 15th Rabochaia street in Omsk.
Financial transparency: the authors have no financial interest in the presented materials or methods. There is no conflict of interest.
About the Authors
D. A. ShevelevRussian Federation
Dmitry A. Shevelev (Omsk, Russia.) – Master Candidate of the Sm-19MA7 group, the Institute of Master and Post-graduate Studies
644080, Omsk, Mira prospekt, 5
V. V. Sirotiuk
Russian Federation
Viktor V. Sirotiuk (Omsk, Russia) – Dr. of Sci., Professor of the Road Design Department
Scopus Author ID 6602369365, Researcher ID B-7877-2019
644008, Omsk, Mira prospekt, 5,
E. A. Gerashchenko
Russian Federation
Elena A. Gerashchenko (Omsk, Russia) – Master Candidate of the Sm-19MA7 group, the Institute of Master and Post-graduate Studies
644080, Omsk, Mira prospekt, 5.,
E. A. Stepanova
Russian Federation
Stepanova A. Elena (Omsk, Russia) – Cand. of Sci., Assosiate Professor of the Technosphere and environmental safety Department
644008, Omsk, Mira prospekt, 5
References
1. Ushakov I.B., Bogomolov A.V., Kukushkin Ju.A. Psihofiziologicheskie mehanizmy formirovanija i razvitija funkcional’nyh sostojanij [Psychophysiological mechanisms of formation and development of functional conditions]. Rossijskij fiziologicheskij zhurnal im. I.M. Sechenova. 2014;100. № 10:1130-1137 (in Russian).
2. Asminin V.F., Korda U.Ju. Analiz putej snizhenija shuma v slozhivshejsja zhiloj zastrojke, prilegajushhej k ostanovochnym punkiam obshhestvennogo transporta [Analysis of ways to reduce noise in the current residential buildings that are adjacent to public transport stops]. Nauchnyj vestnik Voronezhskogo arhitekturno-stroitel’nogo universiteta. Stroitel’stvo i arhitektura. 2010; 4(20): 141-145 (in Russian).
3. Evgen’ev G.I. Primenenie shumozashhitnyh jekranov na avtomobil’nyh dorogah SShA [The use of noise screens on highways of the USA]. Obzornaja Informacija Avtomobil’nye dorogi i mosty. 2005; 5: 50 (in Russian).
4. Highway Noise Barriers: Performance, Maintenance and Safety (Video). Cambridge, MA: John A. Volpe Na-tional Transportation Systems Center, 1996. October.
5. Noise wall design guideline. Design guideline to improve the appearance of noise walls in NSW. March 2016.
6. Bahman Daee. Application of Polyurethane Products in Accelerated Construction of Innovative Noise Barrier. Western Graduate and PostdoctoralStudies. Electronic Thesis and Dissertation Repository, 2864. 2015.
7. Fleming G.G., Knauer H.S., Lee C.S.Y., Pedersen S. Highway Noise Barrier Design Handbook. http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/environment/noise/design/index.htm.
8. Hanson C.E., Towers D.A., and Meister L.D. (2006). Transit Noise and Vibration Impact Assessment. Report № FTA-VA-90-1003-06, prepared by Harris Miller Miller & Hanson, Inc., Burlington, MA, for the Federal Transit Ad-ministration, Washington, DC. Available at http://acousticstoday.org/manual. Accessed September 1, 2016.
9. Goines L., Hagler L. Noise Pollution: A Modern Plague. Southern Medical Journal [online]. 2007; 100 (3): 287–294. Available from: http://docs.wind-watch. org/ goineshaglernoisepollution.html [Accessed 16 January 2017].
10. Questim D. Assessing the acoustic durability of noise barriers on NRA road networks” Phil Morgan, June 2014, TRL, UK.
11. Minaeva V.V., Gaponenko A.V. Vlijanie shuma na organizm cheloveka [The influence of noise on the human body]. Mezhdunarodnyj studencheskij nauchnyj vestnik. 2015; 3: 56–58 (in Russian).
12. Stepanova E.A., Abramova I.A. Sub’ektivnaja ocenka vnutrizhilishhnoj akusticheskoj sredy nasele-niem, prozhivajushhim na urbanizirovannyh primagistral’nyh territorijah [A subjective assessment of the intragilistic acoustic environment by the population living on urbanized areas close to the highways]. Omskij nauchnyj vestnik. 2004; 3: 76 –79 (in Russian).
13. Shashurin A.E. Novye tehnicheskie i tehnologicheskie reshenija dlja snizhenija akusticheskogo zagrjaz-nenija shumozashhitnymi jekranami: monografija [New technical and technological solutions for reducing acoustic pollution with noise-proof screens: monograph.]. SanktPeterburg: BGTU “Voenmeh” im. D.F. Ustinova, 2018: 134. ISBN 978-5-907054-27-1. Available at: https://e.lanbook.com/book/122102 (accessed: 19.04.2020). (in Russian)
14. Voprosy zvukoizoljacii i arhitekturnoj akustiki The issues of sound insulation and architectural acoustics]. Akad. stroitel’stva i arhitektury SSSR. Nauch. -issled. in-t stroit. fiziki i ograzhdajushhih konstrukcij; Pod red. kand. tehn. nauk V.N. Nikol’skogo. Moskow: Gosstrojizdat, 1959: 156 (in Russian).
15. Zinkin V.N., Soldatov S.K., Bogomolov A.V., Dragan S.P. Aktual’nye problemy zashhity naselenija ot nizkochastotnogo shuma i infrazvuka [Actual issues of population protection from low-frequency noise and infrasound]. Tehnologii grazhdanskoj bezopasnosti. 2015; 12. №1(43): 90–93 (in Russian).
16. Ivanov N.I. Problema shuma v sovremennoj civilizacii [The problem of noise in modern civilization // Construction physics in the 20th century: materials of scientific and technical conference]. Stroitel’naja fizika v XXI veke: mate-rialy nauchno-tehnicheskoj konferencii / pod red. I.L. Shubina. M.: NIISF RAASN, 2006: 39–42 (in Russian).
17. Roshhina N.V. Normativnye trebovanija k shumozashhitnym akusticheskim jekranam [Normative requirements for noise-proof acoustic screens]. Noise theory and practice. 2017; 3(9). Tom 3: 46-49. (in Russian)
18. Kuklin D.A., Tjurina A.V. Issledovanie akusticheskih jekranov dlja snizhenija shuma poezdov [Research of acoustic screens for reducing train noise]. Bez-opasnost’ zhiznedejatel’nosti: nauchnoprakticheskij zhurnal. 2009; 8: 30–34 (in Russian).
19. Manakov A.L., Karpushhenko N.I., Velichko D.V. Snizhenie urovnja shuma vblizi zheleznoj dorogi [Reducing the noise level near the railway]. Put’ i putevoe hozjajstvo. 2020; 3: 11–15 (in Russian).
20. Dejnega I.N., Marahovskij S.S. Kompozitnye polimernye materialy v konstrukcijah shumozashhitnyh jekranov [Composite polymer materials in the construction of noise screens. Roads]. Dorogi. Innovacii v stroitel’stve. 2016; 2: 100-102 (in Russian).
21. Fedjaev A.A., Dejnega I.N. K jeffektivnosti shumozashhitnyh jekranov [To the effectiveness of noise screens]. Dorogi. Innovacii v stroitel’stve. 2017; 62: 20-23 (in Russian).
22. Kokodeeva N.E., Nikulushkin A.A. O zakone raspredelenija i ocenke stepeni riska shumovoj harak-teristiki ot transportnogo potoka [On the law of distribution and assessment of the risk of noise characteristics from the transport flow]. Tehnicheskoe regulirovanie v transportnom stroitel’stve. 2014; 1 (5): 6–16 (in Russian).
23. Krikun S.N., Pugachjov I.E. Matematicheskaja model’ ocenki transportnogo shuma [A mathematical model of transport noise assessment]. Nauka i tehnika v dorozhnoj otrasli. 2019; (87): 35–37 (in Russian).
Review
For citations:
Shevelev D.A., Sirotiuk V.V., Gerashchenko E.A., Stepanova E.A. THE IMPACT ANALYSIS OF THE NOISE SCREENS ON THE EXAMPLE OF A TRANSPORT INTERCHANGE IN THE CITY OF OMSK. The Russian Automobile and Highway Industry Journal. 2020;17(2):286-301. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.26518/2071-7296-2020-17-2-286-301